Helicopter Parents

They demand adult behavior but keep us on a tight leash

By Kaiti Hanger

Published February 27, 2009

Kaiti Hanger

Since I’ve entered high school, my parents have asked for consistent phone calls and the who, what, when and where of pretty much all of my plans. I don’t know if it’s the fact that my friends can drive, or they realize that more kids drink and smoke now, but they’ve become a lot more protective than before. Is this overbearing? Yes. Obnoxious? Of course. But they’ve never done anything nearly as ridiculous as some parents out there.

My mother and I have a very honest relationship. She’s not an idiot, and I’m not a good liar, so I see no reason to hide or sugar-coat everything that goes on in high school. For that reason, she gets nervous sometimes when I tell her I’m going to a party or getting a ride home with a friend, but she still gives me freedom because she knows I can take care of myself.

Parents push kids to take AP and Honors courses, get jobs, prepare for careers and act like adults. At the same time, they’re dumbing children down by limiting their social experiences.

I realize that the parents of freshmen are used to their kids going to dances that are during the day, with the lights on and songs like the Cha-Cha Slide and the Chicken Dance playing. And that a lot of early middle school parties involve playing video games and Spin the Bottle. But how much can high school really change how tight your leashes are?

There is a significant line between protecting your child from things that could get them in trouble, and flat-out taking away their freedom and stunting their social growth. As teenagers, we do so many things to prepare for adulthood. We juggle homework, prepare for standardized tests, work on weekends and after school. Not to mention participating in sports, programs and clubs, all to enhance our college application, get into a great school and ultimately, land an amazing job. So you’d think we deserve the right to do what we want in our free time.

A good example is the famous GHS dances. They are usually way filthier than those of other high schools and we take great pride in that. We look forward to letting loose and having fun with our peers. And after all the hard work we do at school, we deserve this, right?

But right when I walked in, ready to dance, I get a purple bracelet slapped on my wrist. And a few minutes into it, numerous kids got them cut off. Not only did this make me paranoid, it made me feel like I was twelve again. I was waiting to be sent over to sit on a bench and made to copy the same paragraph over and over with Ms. Jones. “Protecting” kids only makes us feel like toddlers and aren’t saving us in any way.

Freshman Briana* says her parents have been buckling down even more since high school. “Last year I went to parties and sleepovers every weekend and my parents didn’t ask questions. Now, they just won’t stop. They think there’s always something bad going on.”

“How do you deal when they don’t let you go parties and stuff?” I ask.

“You mean how do I deal almost every weekend? I just sneak around. And if they catch me, what are they gonna do? Not let me go out more?”

Another freshman, Nick*, has a similar struggle. His mom objects to the way kids dance, and constantly complains to her friends about it. “They keep wanting me to grow up. But I still feel like a little kid with the way they’re treating me.”

And if we can’t do what we’ve been doing for years at GHS dances, trust me, we’ll find somewhere else to do it. There will be house parties, likely without any supervision, and themed dance parties that are cheap and have absolutely no regulations besides, “Leave your beef outside.”

If teenagers can’t partake in parties and social events now, they’ll probably do worse things in college, without shelter and limitations. If we can’t make mistakes and learn from them in high school, they’ll be made at a Frat party eventually.

We need to be ready for the real world, starting in high school. Bad influences are everywhere, and we need to make our own decisions. Parents are there to guide us, not keep us under a rock for four years.

2 Responses to “Helicopter Parents”

  1. Hildy Ko says:

    Hi Kaiti!
    This is a great article and I hope some parents read it and instead of talking to their kids actually LISTEN to them. The main thing for parents is to establish trust, which you fortunately have with your mom. Some kids have blown it and then find it hard for parents to re-establish a trusting relationship.

    I am writing an email to a women in charge of froshing this year and telling her to cool her jets. I did not have your email address so will paste the letter in below. Love ya girl!! Hildy
    Hi Jennifer and Garfield Staff and Administrators,

    I saw in Garfield Notes that you were collecting stories and concerns about froshing at Garfield. We have three kids, two of whom are Garfield graduates and are now at college. The culture has changed so much at Garfield in the time we have been there. My kids and I feel there used to be a lot more Bulldog spirit at Garfield. I read the same in the Messenger. Maybe it was the move to Lincoln and then coming back this year, we have still not found our hearts and reconnected in the community. Where is our Bulldog spirit and pride?

    Maybe we should ask the kids?

    I understand issues of safety but some of the frantic wringing of hands over how kid’s dress or dance, and the froshing that happens during spirit week in the name of Bulldog spirit  — are unfounded. The administration and freaked out parents are trying to micromanage everything in the name of safety. Trusting kids to make the right choice is an important step for parents and administrators to take, instead of expecting the worst first! It seems to me that some of the silly stuff the kids do is in the name of fun and spirit, and should not be punished. I do not see how some writing with markers on skin, (that will soon wash off) or dressing underclassman in purple outfits, can be seen as detrimental. My son was quite proud as a freshman to be singled out to wear a purple tutu, it meant he was recognized and valued by his upperclassman. I can see how tossing kids in the lake can be dangerous, but all my kids went for a dip and are proud of following this Bulldog tradition.

    Maybe parents and administrators should cool their jets, engage the students, present the problem and see if they can brainstorm on solutions. When we give our students clear expectations, and then ask the kids to police themselves, I would bet they look out for one another resulting in a positive outcome. The threat of dire punishments for aberrant behavior does not necessarily result in positive behavior. It might be more appropriate for ASB to draft some suggestions about what is expected and give suitable examples of Bulldog pride! If new ideas are solicited from our kids, they are more likely to get on board.

    Perhaps the Messenger could tackle this issue?

    Thanks to everyone for your energy and efforts to educate and safeguard our kids!

  2. howieinseattle says:

    Kaiti:
    As a genuine 100-year-old Garfield parent , I am impressed (again) by your judgment and maturity. I hope my support doesn’t kill your social life.

Leave a Reply